The Philosophical Antecedent of a Thomistic Debate on Human Rights: Revisiting the Maritain–De Koninck Controversy

Maxime St-Hilaire is a full professor in the Université de Sherbrook Faculty of Law.
Introduction
The conventional narrative holds that human rights and their incorporation into positive law represent the culmination of a juridical “modernity” that, at a foundational level, replaced the “classical” natural law of the common good (grounded in the objective order of a plurality of political communities) with the subjective rights of the universal individual. One may thus be struck by the singularity of Jacques Maritain: a Thomist who nevertheless became one of the principal architects of the mid-twentieth-century “human rights revolution.” John Finnis, however, offers a reading of Thomas Aquinas according to which Aquinas not only delineated limits on state authority, embraced the ideal of liberty under the rule of law, and anticipated Lon Fuller’s desiderata of the rule of law but also foreshadowed the very idea of human rights.


