The Freedom to Import Religious Goods: An Analysis of Customs Regulations on Religious Items and Their Interference with Freedom of Religion or Belief: Part One

Brandon Reece Taylorian is an associate lecturer at the University of Central Lancashire (UK). The following is Part One of a two-part post.

Introduction

States have a clear interest in the religious activities of their citizens. This is evident in how authorities apply limitations through law on where, when, and how religious groups propagate their beliefs and gather for worship services.[1] A government equally has a legitimate interest in controlling the flow of goods into a country. However, customs regulations can also restrict imports of religious goods, which in turn restricts the right to freedom of religion or belief (FoRB) of religious communities. Moreover, customs officials in countries with a state religion or a ban on certain denominations are more likely to target items unaligned with the religious or moral norms of the majority or privileged religion, as opposed to more generally targeting taxable items. Academic literature has granted insufficient attention to restriction of religion through customs channels, including to the question of which morality-related import restrictions constitute interference with FoRB.[2]

(more…)

Continue Reading The Freedom to Import Religious Goods: An Analysis of Customs Regulations on Religious Items and Their Interference with Freedom of Religion or Belief: Part One

The Freedom to Import Religious Goods: An Analysis of Customs Regulations on Religious Items and Their Interference with Freedom of Religion or Belief: Part Two

Brandon Reece Taylorian is an associate lecturer at the University of Central Lancashire (UK). The following is Part Two of a two-part post.

Introduction

Part One of this two-part post gave an overview of the range of state policies and practices that restrict importations of religious goods and provided an assessment of when customs regulations inappropriately limit FoRB. Part Two, below, focuses on two 2020 European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) cases involving restrictions on the importation of Jehovah’s Witness literature in Armenia and Azerbaijan, respectively. These cases show how states have applied their import regulations in practice, to the detriment of religious communities. Both cases also illustrate how the ECtHR determines a violation of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in the specific area of religious import restrictions.

(more…)

Continue Reading The Freedom to Import Religious Goods: An Analysis of Customs Regulations on Religious Items and Their Interference with Freedom of Religion or Belief: Part Two